After a delay of one year due to the NFL preseason
players’ strike in 1974, the 41st College All-Star Game was held on August
1, 1975. The Pittsburgh Steelers, having won the first championship in franchise
history the preceding season, represented the professionals while John McKay of
USC coached a group of All-Stars that included 22 first round draft choices.
Pittsburgh, under Head Coach Chuck Noll, featured an
outstanding defense and an offense that also had plenty of talent, with FB
Franco Harris, the Super Bowl MVP, leading the ground attack and a good group
of receivers. QB Terry Bradshaw had regained the starting job that Joe Gilliam (pictured above) had held for the first six games in ‘74, and displayed savvy as the team reached
the top.
The All-Stars included California QB Steve Bartkowski, HB
Walter Payton from Jackson State, and Oregon TE Russ Francis on offense and, on
defense, DT Randy White from Maryland, Jackson State LB Robert Brazile, and
Ohio State CB Neal Colzie. John McKay was coaching the collegians for the
second time (he had also been designated as head coach for the game that was
cancelled the previous year).
There were 54,562 fans in attendance on a Friday night at
Soldier Field. The field was wet after a shower doused it two hours before
kickoff, and it rained throughout the contest.
The All-Stars scored on their first possession, going 80
yards in just four plays. Steve Bartkowski threw to Northwestern WR Larry
Burton for a 48-yard gain and then to WR Pat McInally from Harvard for a
28-yard touchdown and the successful conversion by Maryland PK Steve Mike-Mayer
made it 7-0. However, the receiver suffered a broken leg on the play
The fired-up All-Star defense forced the pro champs to
punt on the next series, but when the Steelers regained possession, they drove
87 yards in 17 plays and tied the score when Bradshaw tossed a two-yard TD pass
to TE Randy Grossman at five minutes into the second quarter, Roy Gerela adding
the PAT. Along the way, Pittsburgh overcame a second-and-24 hole as Bradshaw
passed to WR Ron Shanklin and HB Rocky Bleier to set up a fourth-and-one
situation that the quarterback converted with a plunge into the line. Bradshaw
also completed passes of 20 yards to TE Larry Brown, 11 yards to Bleier, and
nine to FB Reggie Harrison.
On the next Pittsburgh possession, Coach Noll chose to put
many backups into the game, although Bradshaw remained at quarterback. The
Steelers went three-and-out and punted, but on the next play FS Glen Edwards
intercepted a Bartkowski pass. Pittsburgh got a first down on the ensuing series
but ended up having to punt again and, in the most exciting play of the game, DB
Virgil Livers of Western Kentucky returned Bobby Walden’s kick 88 yards. The
return set an All-Star Game record, and, with Mike-Mayer’s conversion, the collegians
took a 14-7 lead into halftime.
The pro champs were further damaged when Franco Harris
and CB Mel Blount left the game with minor injuries during the first half.
Still, Pittsburgh’s other starters were back for the third quarter, although
they continued to have difficulty moving the ball against the tough All-Star
defense. The Steelers managed to pin the All-Stars back inside their one yard
line after a punt, and Neil Clabo had to kick from his end zone after the collegians
went nowhere. The punt was a good one to midfield and the defense again came through,
sacking Bradshaw twice to squelch any threat.
The Steelers were passing more than usual, especially
with Harris sidelined. With three minutes remaining in the period, Pittsburgh
got the ball on a turnover when LB Jack Lambert recovered a Bartkowski fumble.
On a series highlighted by two runs and a pass reception by HB John “Frenchy”
Fuqua, the Steelers advanced to the All-Star 15, but then Florida LB Ralph
Ortega came up with an interception that he returned to his 35.
The All-Stars had difficulty on offense themselves in the
second half, managing just two first downs in the third quarter and none in the
fourth. Bartkowski (pictured below) stayed in the game but was victimized by dropped passes and
untimely holding penalties.
Joe Gilliam relieved Terry Bradshaw in the fourth quarter
and the Steelers came alive on offense. Finishing off a 42-yard series, Gilliam
threw to HB Rocky Bleier for a six-yard TD at less than five minutes into the
final period. Then, with 4:16 left on the clock, Gilliam put the Steelers ahead
with a touchdown pass to WR Frank Lewis that covered 21 yards and capped a
45-yard drive that was set up by a shanked punt. Gerela successfully added the
extra points after each and, after much difficulty, Pittsburgh came away with a
21-14 win.
For all of the trouble that the Steelers had on offense,
they still significantly outgained the All-Stars (287 yards to 123) and had far
more first downs (17 to 4). The All-Stars recorded six sacks of Pittsburgh
quarterbacks to just two of the collegians by the Steelers.
Terry Bradshaw completed 14 of 24 passes for 145 yards with
one touchdown and one interception and Joe Gilliam was successful on five of
his six throws for 50 yards and two TDs while giving up no interceptions. Rocky
Bleier paced Pittsburgh’s ground game with 41 yards on 11 carries and also led
the club with five pass receptions, for 41 yards and a touchdown. Larry Brown
gained 45 yards on his three catches.
For the All-Stars, Steve Bartkowski was successful on 7
of 18 passes for 126 yards and a TD. Russ Francis was the best of the receivers
with two catches for 46 yards and Walter Payton was the leading rusher,
although with only 16 yards on 7 carries.
“Physically, we got the hell kicked out of us,” said an
irritated Chuck Noll afterward, disappointed at his team’s effort. “That’s what
happens when you underestimate somebody.”
The Steelers went on to repeat as NFL Champions, putting
together a 12-2 record in the regular season. While Joe Gilliam played well in
relief of Terry Bradshaw against the College All-Stars, it was Bradshaw guiding
the offense all the way and receiving Pro Bowl recognition for the first time.
Steve Bartkowski went on to play for the Atlanta Falcons,
who had taken him in the first round of the draft, and became a two-time
All-Pro. Walter Payton had a great career with the Chicago Bears that ended
with his topping the NFL career rushing list and gaining enshrinement in the Pro
Football Hall of Fame. Pat McInally, who suffered the broken leg while scoring
the game’s first touchdown, spent ten years with the Cincinnati Bengals,
although he was more productive as a punter than as a pass receiver. Virgil
Livers, who had the long punt return for a score, joined Walter Payton with the
Bears, where he played cornerback and returned kicks for five seasons.
There were concerns about the future of the All-Star
Game, and only one more was played before the series that had started in 1934
came to an end. The win by the Steelers was the 30th for the pro
champs, as against nine for the All-Stars and two ties (Pittsburgh also won the
final contest in ’76).
