1972: Browns Overcome Chargers on Late Pitts Touchdown

The Cleveland Browns had a 5-3 record and were trying to keep pace with the division-leading Steelers as they faced the San Diego Chargers on November 13, 1972. Head Coach Nick Skorich’s team had started off slowly, losing three of its first five contests, but had a three-game winning streak going coming into San Diego. Third-year QB Mike Phipps had been handed the starting duties in the second week of the season and displayed poise. HB Leroy Kelly and FB Bo Scott were aging but still dependable runners. The defense had problems against the run but, with young CB Clarence Scott and FS Thom Darden in the backfield, was sound against the pass.

The Chargers, under Head Coach Harland Svare, were heading in the opposite direction. They had lost four straight games and were a dismal 2-5-1. QB John Hadl had been effective in the team’s former pass-oriented offense, but bridled with the switch to a ground-based attack that featured HB Mike Garrett and FB Cid Edwards. San Diego had invested heavily in aging players, and it was not proving to be a sound strategy.

There were 54,205 fans on hand for the Monday night game at San Diego Stadium. The Chargers drove methodically down the field on their opening possession. They kept the ball on the ground with Garrett and Edwards carrying the load and John Hadl throwing to Garrett for a 13-yard gain on a third-and-three play. However, after going 73 yards to reach the Cleveland four yard line, Hadl fumbled and DE Bob Briggs recovered for the Browns. The teams traded punts for the remainder of the first quarter.

In the second quarter, the Chargers put together another long drive of 49 yards that ended with Dennis Partee kicking a 26-yard field goal. After another exchange of punts, the Browns started off at their 33 and moved the ball effectively themselves. WR Frank Pitts gained 13 yards on a reverse and Leroy Kelly ran for 11 yards and caught a pass from Mike Phipps for a 27-yard gain. Phipps threw to Bo Scott for 24 yards and, after a pass interference penalty moved the ball to the San Diego one, Phipps gained the last yard for a touchdown on a quarterback sneak. Don Cockroft added the extra point and Cleveland was ahead by 7-3, which remained the score at halftime.

The Browns took the second half kickoff and drove to midfield before LB Rick Redman intercepted a Phipps pass. They got the ball back two plays later when Garrett fumbled for the Chargers, but ended up having to punt. San Diego proceeded to go 86 yards in 12 plays. Hadl completed three passes, a key one of which was to WR Gary Garrison for 15 yards in a third-and-12 situation, and the last for a four-yard touchdown to Edwards. Partee added the PAT and the Chargers took a 10-7 lead into the fourth quarter.

Cleveland was on the move as the third quarter ended, with Phipps tossing an 18-yard completion to TE Milt Morin on third down to close out the period and then starting off the final quarter with a 19-yard pass to Pitts that reached the San Diego 33. Seven plays later, FB Ken Brown went two yards up the middle for a touchdown and, with Cockroft’s extra point, the visitors were back in front at 14-10.

The teams traded punts before the Chargers came back with another score. Starting off at their 39, they primarily stayed on the ground as Garrett and Edwards ran well and Hadl threw to Garrison for a 15-yard gain. Garrett capped the drive with a three-yard touchdown run. Partee added the PAT and, with 1:21 remaining to play, San Diego appeared to be in control and set for an upset with a three-point edge.

After HB Bill LeFear ran the kickoff back 24 yards, the Browns started off from their own 36. Phipps tossed a screen pass to Brown for seven yards and then connected with the fullback again for a 19-yard gain. On the next play, Phipps went long for Pitts in the end zone, and he pulled it down for a 38-yard touchdown. With Cockroft’s extra point, Cleveland was suddenly ahead by four.

There were still 33 seconds left on the clock as the Chargers took possession at their 13 following a clipping penalty on the kickoff return. Hadl completed a pass to TE Pettis Norman for 24 yards to the Cleveland 45, but two more passes fell incomplete to end the game. The Browns came away with a 21-17 win.

The Chargers had the edge in total yards (327 to 299) and first downs (24 to 18), and were especially effective on the ground, where they generated 191 yards of their total. However, San Diego also turned the ball over three times, to one suffered by Cleveland.

Frank Pitts was the star on offense for the Browns as he caught 5 passes for 96 yards, including the game-winning touchdown, and despite suffering from a back injury. Mike Phipps completed 13 of 21 throws for 186 yards and a TD with one intercepted and also ran for 17 yards and a score on four carries. Leroy Kelly rushed for 67 yards on 17 attempts.

For the Chargers, Cid Edwards (pictured at left) gained 91 yards on 17 rushes and had three pass receptions for 34 more yards and a TD. Mike Garrett contributed 89 yards on 24 attempts and also scored a touchdown in addition to catching a team-high four passes for 29 yards. John Hadl was successful on 12 of 21 tosses for 140 yards with one touchdown and one interception. Pettis Norman led the club with 47 yards on his three catches. 

“Everybody wasn’t playing the same defense, particularly on that last series,” said a frustrated Coach Harland Svare. “It’s downright silly to let them go that long, that fast for a score.”

The win kept the Browns a game behind the Steelers, who they defeated the next week. The winning streak reached six games and the loss in the return engagement at Pittsburgh was the only one the team suffered for the remainder of the regular season. Cleveland ended up with a 10-4 record, good enough for second in the AFC Central and a Wild Card spot in the playoffs. The Browns gave the undefeated Dolphins a good scare in the Divisional round of the postseason before falling. The Chargers, meanwhile, continued to struggle and finished at 4-9-1 and at the bottom of the AFC West.

Mike Phipps (pictured below) went through his ups and downs, completing just 47.2 percent of his passes for 1994 yards with 13 touchdowns and 16 interceptions. Still, the team did well, although Phipps would never develop into the star that Cleveland had hoped he would be when they traded up for him (and gave up Hall of Fame WR Paul Warfield in doing so) in the first round of the 1970 NFL draft.

Frank Pitts continued to be Cleveland’s most reliable receiver, leading the club with 36 catches for 620 yards (17.2 avg.) and eight touchdowns.

The running back tandem of Mike Garrett and Cid Edwards remained a bright spot in an otherwise dreadful year for the Chargers. Garrett rushed for 1031 yards on 272 carries (3.8 avg.) and caught 31 passes for 245 more yards, ending up with a total of seven touchdowns. Cid Edwards ran for 679 yards on 157 attempts (4.3 avg.) and had 40 pass receptions for 557 yards, with an impressive 13.9 average per catch out of the backfield. He also scored a total of seven TDs and was named team MVP.

2001: Ravens Stop McNair on Last Play to Beat Titans

The Baltimore Ravens, defending NFL Champions, had gotten off to a slow start in the 2001 season but were coming off back-to-back wins and were 5-3 as they faced the Tennessee Titans on November 12. Head Coach Brian Billick’s team had reached the Super Bowl following the 2000 season thanks to a superb defense and ball-control offense. The defense was still strong, and while QB Elvis Grbac had been signed away from the Chiefs to upgrade the passing attack, RB Jamal Lewis, key to the ground game as a rookie, was out for the year with a knee injury suffered during training camp.

The Tennessee Titans, coached by Jeff Fisher, were struggling at 3-4 after having put together consecutive 13-3 records and winning an AFC title in 1999. QB Steve McNair was playing well but RB Eddie George appeared to be on the downside of his fine career and injuries were a problem, especially with the once-formidable defense. The Ravens had won convincingly when the teams met at Baltimore five weeks earlier and, coming into the rematch, McNair was suffering from a sinus infection and was not at full strength.

There were 68,798 fans in attendance at Nashville’s Adelphia Coliseum for the Monday night game. The teams traded punts during the first quarter, with neither offense able to move. A promising series for the Ravens was highlighted by back-to-back pass completions by Elvis Grbac to WR Brandon Stokley for 18 yards on a third-and-seven play and 16 yards to FB Sam Gash.  But after reaching the Tennessee 33, Grbac was sacked for a seven-yard loss by DE Jevon Kearse on a third down play and they had to punt.

Early in the second quarter, the Titans put together a long drive that started at their nine yard line and reached the Baltimore 30. Steve McNair completed four passes, two of which converted third downs, and also ran for 13 yards while Eddie George contributed 26 yards on seven carries. However, they came up empty when Joe Nedney’s 48-yard field goal attempt was unsuccessful.

The Ravens responded by moving into Tennessee territory, but a Grbac pass was intercepted by LB Keith Bulluck. With 3:35 remaining in the half, the Titans put together another long series. At one point, McNair completed three straight passes for 25 yards to reach the Baltimore six, but the drive stalled there and a field goal by Nedney was wiped out by a holding penalty. The second try for a field goal had to be aborted due to a bad snap and holder Craig Hentrich’s desperation pass was intercepted. The game remained scoreless at halftime.

The Titans got a break early in the third quarter when WR Qadray Ismail fumbled after catching a pass and DB Daryl Porter recovered near midfield. They were unable to capitalize, however, but following a punt they got the ball back on another Baltimore turnover, this time the result of a botched punt. Getting the ball with first-and-goal at the Ravens’ eight, the Titans still couldn’t reach the end zone but finally broke the scoreless deadlock with a 27-yard Nedney field goal.

The Ravens came right back when WR Jermaine Lewis returned the ensuing kickoff 76 yards to the Tennessee 16. They also ended up having to settle for a field goal by Matt Stover from 31 yards to make it 3-3. The Titans responded with an eight-play, 71-yard drive. McNair threw six passes, including one to TE Brian Natkin for 27 yards and the last to WR Kevin Dyson for a 22-yard touchdown. Nedney added the extra point and Tennessee was ahead by 10-3.

Now it was time for the Ravens to move on offense. RB Jason Brookins ran three times for 18 yards and Grbac completed two passes to Ismail, the second for a 57-yard TD. Stover’s extra point again knotted the score.

Heading into the fourth quarter, the Ravens got another break on a turnover when George fumbled and LB Peter Boulware recovered at the Tennessee 18. Four plays later Stover kicked a 33-yard field goal that put the visitors back in front at 13-10.

The teams traded punts until, starting at their 14 yard line with 8:17 remaining to play, the Ravens put together another scoring drive. Grbac thew to TE Shannon Sharpe for 15 yards in a third-and-six situation and Brookins had a 25-yard run to the Tennessee 27. The eleven-play series ended with Stover kicking another field goal, this time from 30 yards, to put Baltimore ahead by six points with the clock now showing 3:10 to go.

Following WR Derrick Mason’s 22-yard kickoff return, the Titans moved methodically down the field. McNair completed a 10-yard pass to Dyson on a third-and-six play and, after being sacked by Boulware for a loss of six yards, had four straight completions to get the ball to the Baltimore 35. A roughing-the-passer penalty added another 15 yards and McNair then threw to George for eight yards to the 12.

McNair’s next pass fell incomplete but, on third-and-two, he hit Mason for six yards. The Titans took their final timeout and McNair missed on his next two throws before connecting with Dyson for five yards down to the one. On fourth down, and lining up quickly with the final seconds ticking away, McNair appeared to score on a quarterback sneak, but a flag was thrown for an offsides penalty.

Following a great deal of confusion and consultation by the officials, the play was ruled a dead-ball foul and, with the ball a foot away from the goal line, the Titans were given one last shot. Once again McNair kept the ball (pictured at top) and, when he couldn’t penetrate the middle of the line, tried to go outside. He was stopped short of the goal line by SS Corey Harris and the Ravens were winners in dramatic fashion by a final score of 16-10.

The Titans won the statistical battle, accumulating more total yards (318 to 238) and first downs (20 to 12), and held onto the ball for 35 minutes. The Ravens accumulated just 55 yards of their total in the first half. Baltimore recorded six sacks, to three by Tennessee, and both teams turned the ball over twice.

Elvis Grbac completed 15 of 27 passes for 192 yards with a touchdown and an interception. Qadray Ismail (pictured at right) had 8 catches for 129 yards and a TD. With veteran RB Terry Allen lost to an injury after one carry, rookie Jason Brookins ran for 57 yards on 14 attempts.

For the Titans, Steve McNair went to the air 48 times and completed 27 of those throws for 256 yards and a TD with none intercepted. He also ran the ball 6 times for 19 yards. Derrick Mason had 12 pass receptions for 99 yards and Kevin Dyson contributed 6 catches for 68 yards and a score. Eddie George rushed for 71 yards on 22 attempts.

“We knew that’s the only thing they wanted to do,” said Baltimore LB Ray Lewis regarding the game-ending quarterback sneak attempt by McNair. “They weren’t going to put the ball in someone else’s hands. If you watch film on them, you know that they run quarterback sneaks an awful lot.”

When asked why the Titans didn’t attempt a pass on the last play, Coach Fisher replied “we thought we’d jam it in, and the game was going to be over.”

The Ravens lost to the Browns the next week but won the next two on the way to a 10-6 record and second place finish in the AFC Central. They won in the first round of the postseason but lost to the division-rival Steelers in the Divisional playoff game. Tennessee continued to struggle and ended up at 7-9 for fourth place in the division.

MVP Profile: Bob Sanders, 2007

Safety, Indianapolis Colts

Age: 26

4^th season in pro football & with Colts

College: Iowa

Height: 5’8”   Weight: 206

Prelude:

Attracted by his speed and athleticism, the Colts selected Sanders in the second round of the 2004 NFL draft. While he was limited to six games as a rookie due to a holdout and injuries, he showed off a physical style of play that belied his size and also performed well in coverage. Sanders excelled in 2005, achieving consensus first-team All-NFL honors as well as being selected to the Pro Bowl. However, a knee injury limited him to four games in 2006.

2007 Season Summary

Appeared in 15 of 16 games

[Bracketed numbers indicate league rank in Top 20]

Sacks – 3.5

Most sacks, game – 2.5 at Tennessee 9/16

Interceptions – 2

Most interceptions, game – 1 at Jacksonville 10/22, vs. Houston 12/23

Int. return yards – 32

Most int. return yards, game – 29 (on 1 int.) vs. Houston 12/23

Int. TDs – 0

Fumble recoveries – 1

Forced fumbles – 0

Tackles – 71

Assists – 25

Postseason: 1 G (AFC Divisional playoff vs. San Diego)

Sacks – 0

Interceptions – 0

Awards & Honors:

NFL Defensive Player of the Year: AP

1^st team All-NFL: AP, PFWA, Sporting News

Pro Bowl

Colts went 13-3 to finish first in the AFC South while leading the NFL in fewest points allowed (262) and the AFC in fewest passing yards allowed (2764). Lost AFC Divisional playoff to San Diego Chargers (28-24).

Aftermath:

The outstanding season in 2007 was followed by four injury-plagued years as Sanders’ hard-hitting style of play began to take a toll. He appeared in only six games in 2008 and three over the next two seasons before being released. Sanders caught on with San Diego for 2011 but appeared in two games before being shelved by a knee injury. Over the course of eight seasons, Sanders intercepted 6 passes and was credited with 226 tackles and 78 assists. However, he played in just 50 games, only twice appearing in more than six in a season –yet achieving consensus first-team All-NFL and Pro Bowl honors in those two seasons.

--

MVP Profiles feature players who were named MVP or Player of the Year in the NFL, AAFC (1946-49), AFL (1960-69), WFL (1974), or USFL (1983-85) by a recognized organization (Associated Press, Pro Football Writers Association, Newspaper Enterprise Association, United Press International, The Sporting News, Maxwell Club – Bert Bell Award, or the league itself). Also includes Associated Press NFL Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year.

1985: Eagles Beat Falcons on Quick’s 99-Yard TD in Overtime

Neither of the teams that faced each other on November 10, 1985 in Philadelphia were doing particularly well as they reached the tenth week of the season. The host Eagles, coached by Marion Campbell, had a 4-5 record after losing at San Francisco the previous week, although they were showing signs of life after a 1-4 start. 34-year-old QB Ron Jaworski operated behind a mediocre offensive line. WR Mike Quick (pictured above) was an established star and RB Earnest Jackson, obtained from the Chargers, was a workmanlike runner. The defense featured DE Reggie White, a newcomer from the USFL who joined the club four weeks into the season, and FS Wes Hopkins.

Things were much worse for Head Coach Dan Henning’s Falcons, who were at 1-8. The top performer on offense was RB Gerald Riggs. Long-time QB Steve Bartkowski had been supplanted by David Archer, who was far more mobile but also less talented as a passer. Injuries had affected the defensive backfield and the linebackers were a mediocre unit.

There were 63,694 fans in attendance at Veterans Stadium on a sunny and mild afternoon. The Eagles had the first possession and punted. Atlanta drove into Philadelphia territory helped by two third down conversions. QB David Archer ran for 14 yards in a third-and-seven situation and Gerald Riggs picked up 12 yards up the middle on a third-and-two play. However, after reaching the Philadelphia 34, Archer threw a pass that was intercepted by SS Ray Ellis.

The Eagles went 54 yards in ten plays that extended into the beginning of the second quarter. Ron Jaworski completed three passes along the way, including one to WR Kenny Jackson for 21 yards in a third-and-eight situation and another to WR Ron Johnson for 10 yards on third-and-eight. That set up an eight-yard touchdown carry by Earnest Jackson and, with Paul McFadden’s extra point, the home team held a 7-0 lead.

Following an Atlanta punt, the Eagles started off with Jaworski throwing to Mike Quick for a 39-yard gain, but the drive stalled in Falcons territory and Philadelphia had to punt. The Eagles got the ball right back when Archer was picked off by CB Herman Edwards. Starting at the Atlanta 40, Jaworski threw to Johnson for 37 yards and, after three runs by Earnest Jackson picked up two yards, Jaworski carried the ball himself on fourth down for a TD. With McFadden’s kick, Philadelphia was up by 14-0. Neither offense was able to get anything going for the remainder of the half.

The Falcons punted following their first series of the third quarter and Philadelphia again drove to a score, going 57 yards in 12 plays. Earnest Jackson ran well and Jaworski threw to TE John Spagnola for 12 yards in a third-and-four situation. The drive stalled at the Atlanta 13 but McFadden kicked a 30-yard field goal to extend Philadelphia’s lead to 17-0.

The teams traded punts until the Falcons put together an 84-yard series that went into the final period. Archer had two throws to WR Stacey Bailey for 18 yards apiece and Riggs ran effectively. Finally, Archer threw to RB Joe Washington for an 18-yard touchdown and, adding Mick Luckhurst’s PAT, Philadelphia’s lead was cut to ten points.

The Eagles went three-and-out on their next series and Atlanta again responded with a scoring drive, this time using 11 plays to go 81 yards. Riggs had six carries for 42 yards and Archer ran twice himself for 19 more yards. The last rush by Riggs was for a one-yard TD and, with Luckhurst’s successful conversion, it was a 17-14 score with 5:30 left in regulation.

On the next play from scrimmage, LB John Rade intercepted a Jaworski pass to give the Falcons the ball at the Philadelphia 25. Atlanta largely kept the ball on the ground to get down to the 10 and Luckhurst tied the game with a 27-yard field goal.

The Eagles had to punt on their next series and Atlanta drove into Philadelphia territory on a possession highlighted by Archer’s throw to TE Arthur Cox for 30 yards. But with nine seconds remaining, Luckhurst was wide to the left on a 42-yard field goal attempt and the game went into overtime.

The Falcons had the ball first in the extra period and were forced to punt, but Rick Donnelly’s 62-yard kick went out of bounds at the Philadelphia one. Jaworski went right to the air, tossing a pass intended for Kenny Jackson that fell incomplete. He went to the air again, and this time he didn’t miss as Quick, running a slant pattern and splitting CB Bobby Butler and SS Scott Case, pulled it in at the 30 yard line and went the distance for a 99-yard touchdown. In stunning fashion at 1:49 into overtime, and after having blown a 17-0 lead, the Eagles came away winners by a score of 23-17. It was the first overtime win in franchise history.

The 99-yard touchdown was the longest pass play to decide an overtime game in NFL history and tied the league record that was first set in 1939. Jaworski and Quick became the sixth combination to accomplish the feat (through 2012, seven more had done so).

Philadelphia had the edge in total yards (330 to 310) although the Falcons generated more first downs (20 to 15). Atlanta also had 215 rushing yards, but only 94 net passing yards. The Eagles sacked David Archer six times while the Falcons got to Ron Jaworski on three occasions. Each team suffered two turnovers.

Ron Jaworski completed just 11 of 30 passes for 258 yards and the one touchdown while tossing two interceptions. Mike Quick, with the long score to win the game, had three catches for 145 yards. Earnest Jackson (pictured at right) paced the ground game with 74 yards on 19 carries that included a TD. DE Reggie White and NT Ken Clarke each accounted for two sacks.

For the Falcons, Gerald Riggs rushed for 129 yards and a touchdown on 27 carries. David Archer gained 70 yards on 10 rushing attempts while completing 12 of his 25 throws for 133 yards and a TD and had two intercepted. Stacey Bailey had 5 pass receptions for 51 yards.

“We got beat on a great play by a great athlete,” said Atlanta’s Coach Henning afterward. “If we have to get beat, that’s the way I’d like to see us get beat.”

The Eagles won the next week to briefly rise over .500, but then lost four straight games and finished at 7-9, which placed them fourth in the NFC East. By the end, Coach Campbell was gone – he would resurface as defensive coordinator of the Falcons the next year and would succeed Dan Henning in 1987. Atlanta also came back with a win the following week and ended up with a 4-12 record, putting them at the bottom of the NFC West.

Mike Quick caught 73 passes for a NFC-leading 1247 yards (17.1 avg.) and 11 touchdowns. He was a consensus first-team All-NFL selection for the second time and was named to the Pro Bowl for the third straight year.

Gerald Riggs led the NFC in rushing with 1719 yards on a league-topping 397 carries (4.3 avg.) and scored 10 TDs. He was chosen to the Pro Bowl for the first of three consecutive years. 

1980: Giants Upset Cowboys with Help of Flea-Flicker to Friede

The New York Giants won their opening game of the 1980 NFL season, but by the time they hosted the Dallas Cowboy s on November 9 they had lost eight straight contests. In their second year under Head Coach Ray Perkins, injuries had decimated the team on both sides of the ball. Third-year QB Phil Simms was a work in progress and had a productive receiver to throw to in WR Earnest Gray, but with injuries badly affecting the rest of the offense, in particular the running game, the Giants had difficulty scoring – they were averaging just 10 points per contest. Likewise, the defense was a patchwork outfit, especially at linebacker. Outstanding players like Brad Van Pelt and Harry Carson were standouts in a patchwork unit.

The Cowboys, perennial contenders under Head Coach Tom Landry, came into the game at 7-2 and had won their previous two contests. Despite concerns following the retirement of star QB Roger Staubach after the ’79 season, former backup QB Danny White was playing well in his place. Wide receivers Drew Pearson and Tony Hill were outstanding, and RB Tony Dorsett was one of the NFL’s best. The defense was solid up front, helped by the return of DE Ed “Too Tall” Jones, who briefly retired in 1979 to try his hand at boxing, making up for inexperience in the backfield.

There were 68,343 fans present at Giants Stadium in the New Jersey Meadowlands. In the first quarter, the home team got the initial break of the game when LB Brad Van Pelt intercepted a Danny White pass.  The resulting drive was helped along by a personal foul penalty called on CB Benny Barnes that added 15 yards to a 22-yard pass from Simms to Earnest Gray. Simms connected with Gray for a 25-yard touchdown and, with Joe Danelo’s extra point, a 7-0 lead.

Less than three minutes later, the Cowboys came back with a one-yard touchdown carry by Tony Dorsett that was set up by a pass interference call on CB Mark Haynes. Rafael Septien added the PAT and the score remained tied after a quarter of action.

Early in the second quarter, New York CB Mike Dennis picked off a White pass and the Giants drove 22 yards to a one-yard touchdown carry by RB Larry Heater. The next Dallas series was highlighted by a 56-yard Dorsett run that set up a one-yard scoring carry by FB Robert Newhouse. The score was knotted at 14-14.

Van Pelt intercepted another pass and the Giants used four plays to score again. Simms threw to Heater for a 29-yard gain and ended the series with a four-yard throw to George Martin, normally a defensive end but lined up as a tight end in short-yardage situations on offense (it was the only catch of his 14-year career with the Giants). Again the Cowboys gave up an interception, this time by FS Gary Woolford. The ensuing possession led to another one-yard touchdown carry by FB Leon Perry, a rookie starting his first game, and, with all of the PATs successful, the Giants were ahead by 28-14.

Dallas narrowed the margin before the first half ended with another big play as White threw a screen pass to FB Ron Springs that resulted in a 58-yard touchdown. Still, the halftime score was a surprising 28-21 in favor of the home team.

In the third quarter, the Cowboys seemed to take control as they scored another touchdown on a 29-yard run by Newhouse.  With the score tied at 28-28, the Giants missed an opportunity when an apparent Simms scoring pass to Gray was nullified by an offensive pass interference penalty on Perry. Dallas proceeded to take the lead as Dorsett ran for a TD from 13 yards out and the Cowboys were up by 35-28 heading into the final period.

In the fourth quarter, the Giants rebounded with Simms throwing to TE Tom Mullady for a 20-yard TD. The Cowboys fought back as time ran down, but in a key defensive play, Van Pelt (pictured at left) stopped Newhouse short on a fourth-and-one carry at the Dallas 47 and the Giants took over with 2:22 left on the clock.

With the rain falling heavily, Simms handed off to Perry, who then flipped the ball back to the quarterback, and he in turn fired deep down the right sideline for WR Mike Friede and a 40-yard gain. CB Steve Wilson slipped and Friede, lunging for the catch, made it to the Dallas seven on the flea-flicker. Three running plays lost two yards and, following a time out, Danelo kicked a 27-yard field goal to put the Giants ahead by three.

There was still time for the Cowboys, and White threw to TE Billy Joe Dupree for 24 yards to the New York 46. He followed up by connecting with WR Butch Johnson for 11 yards and then to Drew Pearson, who gained six yards and got out of bounds to stop the clock, which was now down to 19 seconds.  The Cowboys decided to try another pass to get closer, but White’s throw intended for Tony Hill was intercepted by Woolford when the receiver slipped and fell down. Woolford barely kept his feet in bounds as he made the catch that nailed down the stunning 38-35 win for the Giants.

New York had the edge in total yards (462 to 294) and first downs (26 to 21) despite the Cowboys rolling up 239 yards on the ground. Dallas was hurt by five turnovers, all on interceptions, to two suffered by the Giants, and, in a game with many penalties, the Cowboys were flagged 12 times as opposed to New York’s nine.

Phil Simms completed 18 of 33 passes for 351 yards and three touchdowns with one intercepted. Mike Friede caught 7 of those throws for 137 yards and Earnest Gray contributed four receptions for 68 yards and a TD. Larry Heater ran for 69 yards and a touchdown on 24 carries and gained another 85 yards on three catches. Brad Van Pelt, who had an outstanding all-around defensive performance, and Gary Woolford each had two interceptions.

For the Cowboys, Tony Dorsett (pictured below) rushed for 183 yards on 24 attempts with two TDs and Robert Newhouse added 52 yards on 10 carries, also scoring twice. However, Danny White completed just 10 of his 23 throws for 155 yards and a TD, giving up five interceptions. Tony Hill and Drew Pearson each had three catches, for 36 and 22 yards, respectively, while Ron Springs, on his one long scoring catch, led the club with 58 receiving yards.

“It’s one of those plays that you put in and hope it works,” said Phil Simms of the crucial flea-flicker that set up the game-winning field goal. “I told Leon if he was in doubt, not to pitch it back.”

“We practiced it all week, but never in a torrential downpour,” added Leon Perry.

“We got ambushed,” said a shrugging Tony Dorsett, summing up the upset. “We were playing a team with a 1-8 record. Emotionally, we were not as high as we would have been against a team with a better record.”

The win by the Giants over Dallas was the first since 1974, a string of 12 straight games that included the first encounter of the year between the clubs five weeks earlier. New York put together another solid performance in a win over the Packers the next week, but lost four of their last five contests to end up at the bottom of the NFC East with a 4-12 record. The Cowboys recovered to win four straight and five of their last six, just barely missing out on winning the division title at 12-4. Settling for a Wild Card playoff spot, they advanced to the NFC Championship game before falling to the division-rival Eagles.

Phil Simms (pictured below) continued his development process until a shoulder injury cost him the last three games of the season. He passed for 2321 yards with 15 touchdowns and 19 interceptions. Mike Friede, a rookie cut earlier by Detroit, proved to be a pleasant surprise for the Giants. He caught 21 passes for 350 yards (16.7 avg.) but lasted just one more season.

Tony Dorsett ended up tying for sixth in rushing (with Buffalo’s Joe Cribbs) with 1185 yards – the fourth straight thousand-yard rushing season to start his career. He carried 278 times and had 11 touchdowns.

Rookie of the Year: Jimmy Orr, 1958

Offensive End/Punter, Pittsburgh Steelers

Age: 23 (Oct. 4)

College: Georgia

Height: 5’11” Weight: 195

Prelude:

Orr’s college career started at Clemson and he moved to Wake Forest before settling in at Georgia, where he made the football team as a walk-on halfback. He twice led the SEC in pass receiving and was chosen to play in the Blue-Gray All-Star Game. The Los Angeles Rams chose him in the 25^th round of the NFL draft with the aim of using him as a defensive back but, after getting a shot at offensive end in a preseason game against the Steelers, drew Pittsburgh’s attention. The Steelers swung a trade for Orr prior to the regular season.

1958 Season Summary

Appeared in all 12 games

[Bracketed numbers indicate league rank in Top 20]

Pass Receiving

Receptions – 33 [17, tied with Ollie Matson]     
Most receptions, game - 6 (for 205 yds.) vs. Chi. Cardinals  12/13

Yards – 910 [3]

Average gain – 27.6 [1]

TDs – 7 [5, tied with four others]
200-yard receiving games - 1
100-yard receiving games - 5

Rushing

Attempts – 1

Yards – 8

TDs – 0

Punting

Punts – 51 [6]

Yards – 2023 [8]

Average – 39.7 [10]

Punts blocked – 0

Longest punt – 62 yards

Scoring

TDs – 7 [14, tied with six others]

Points – 42

Awards & Honors:

NFL Rookie of the Year: UPI

2^nd team All-NFL: AP, UPI

Steelers went 7-4-1 to finish third in the Eastern Conference while leading the NFL in passing yards (2752). It was the team’s best record since 1947.

Aftermath:

Orr followed up with 35 catches for 604 yards (17.3 avg.) and was chosen for the Pro Bowl in 1959 while also gaining first-team All-NFL recognition from The Sporting News. The numbers dropped to 29 receptions and 541 yards in ’60, but his average gain rose to 18.7 and he was still considered to be one of the NFL’s better receivers (he didn’t punt again after his second year). Orr was traded to the Baltimore Colts for 1961 and, hobbled by a series of nagging leg injuries, caught only 18 passes, but bounced back in ’62 with career highs of 55 catches, 974 yards, and 11 TDs. He continued to be a steady flanker for the Colts, again leading the NFL by averaging 21.7 yards per catch on 40 receptions in 1964 and 25.6 yards on 29 catches in ’68. In 1965 he was a consensus first-team All-NFL honoree as well as a Pro Bowl selection after catching 45 passes for 847 yards and 10 TDs. Injuries and the presence of talented younger receivers limited Orr’s effectiveness in 1967 and his last two years, 1969 and ’70. Over the course of 13 seasons, he caught 400 passes for 7914 yards (19.8 avg.) and 66 touchdowns and was twice selected to the Pro Bowl.

--

Rookie of the Year Profiles feature players who were named Rookie of the Year in the NFL, AFL (1960-69), or USFL (1983-85) by a recognized organization (Associated Press – Offense or Defense, Newspaper Enterprise Association, United Press International, The Sporting News, or the league itself – Pepsi NFL Rookie of the Year). 
[Updated 2/21/17]

1925: Yellow Jackets Knock Akron Out of First in Upset

The Frankford Yellow Jackets, sponsored by the Frankford Athletic Association in Philadelphia, were sporting an 8-1 record (with one more win in a non-league contest) as they hosted the Akron Pros on November 7, 1925. While previously a successful independent team, the Yellow Jackets were in their second year as a NFL franchise. For 1925, they were guided by Guy Chamberlin (pictured at right), who played end in addition to his coaching duties. Successful as a player-coach in Canton and Cleveland, where his teams won NFL titles, it was hoped that he would bring the same results to Philadelphia.

Akron was undefeated at 4-0-2 coming into the game against the Yellow Jackets (schedules were not yet standardized in the NFL), and thus at the top of the standings. Coached by end Scotty Bierce, the team had regained the services of tailback Fritz Pollard, former Brown All-American and star of the team’s 1920 championship season as well as player-coach in 1921 (thus becoming the first African-American to be a head coach in the NFL). The Pros had fallen upon hard times after Pollard’s departure, posting losing records in each of the next three seasons.

There were 12,000 enthusiastic fans in attendance at Philadelphia’s Frankford Stadium for the Saturday afternoon contest (Pennsylvania blue laws prevented Sunday games). Early in the first quarter, the Yellow Jackets had the ball at their 45 yard line. FB Hust Stockton surprised the Pros with a pass to end Rae Crowther (pictured below), who caught it at the Akron 40 and went the distance for a 55-yard touchdown. Bull Behman, a star tackle as well as kicker, added the extra point for a 7-0 lead. Before the first quarter was over, Behman kicked a 20-yard field goal to extend Frankford’s margin to 10-0.

In the second quarter, the Yellow Jackets again put together a drive into Akron territory. After reaching the 20, it appeared that they were maneuvering for another field goal. However, back Tex Hamer threw across the field to Crowther at the five, and the end proceeded to the end zone for another TD. Behman again added the extra point and the home team took a surprising 17-0 lead into halftime.

The Pros attempted to come back in the second half, gaining yards with Fritz Pollard leading the way, but failing to score. Finally, an Akron drive ended in a fourth quarter score. Pollard set up a short plunge by FB Dunc Annan and Obie Newman added the extra point. That was all the Pros could do, however, and Frankford came away with a convincing 17-7 upset.

It was reported that Pollard went to the air 20 times and completed most of his passes, displaying great accuracy. He also ran the ball effectively. For Akron, in addition to Pollard, guard Al Nesser was a standout on defense – and all the more noticeable by his not wearing a helmet.

The Yellow Jackets headed off to Chicago for a game the next day against the Bears that they lost. They went on to lose five of their last nine contests, playing more league games than most teams because of their tendency to schedule Sunday road contests following their Saturday home games, to end up with a 13-7 record. That placed them sixth in the 20-team NFL. The Pros lost again to the Pottsville Maroons and finished fifth at 4-2-2.

There was some controversy surrounding Frankford later in the season. Following a lopsided 49-0 loss to the Pottsville Maroons, Coach Chamberlin, who missed time on the field due to a shoulder separation, suspended Bull Behman for indifferent play. He made explicit to the rest of the team that others would follow if the performance didn’t improve and the future Pro Football Hall of Famer led by example as he returned to action for the next contest – a return encounter against the Bears and their new acquisition, star HB Red Grange. Chicago again prevailed, but had to overcome a strong effort by the fired-up Yellow Jackets to do so.